Cacio e Pepe with Olive Oil & Butter: A Silky Roman Classic
📜 Introduction
Cacio e Pepe with Olive Oil and Butter is more than a trendy twist — it’s a creamy, flavorful evolution of one of Italy’s oldest pasta traditions. On Donald Recipes, I treat this classic as more than a recipe; it’s a celebration of Roman simplicity and modern culinary finesse.
The origins of Cacio e Pepe with Olive Oil and Butter trace back to ancient shepherds from the Lazio region. The traditional version of cacio e pepe, which translates to “cheese and pepper,” relies on just three simple ingredients: pasta, freshly ground black pepper, and Pecorino Romano. But today’s buttery variation transforms the original into a silken masterpiece, combining butter and olive oil to eliminate clumping and amplify flavor.
🧀 A Roman Treasure Turned Global Comfort Food
While Cacio e Pepe with Olive Oil and Butter retains its Roman heart, it’s now a global favorite. Foodies worldwide are drawn to its rich, cheesy emulsion and bold pepper kick. Its rise in popularity reflects the desire for minimalist meals with gourmet impact.
🌎 Leading 10 Nations That Embrace Cacio e Pepe the Most:
- 🇮🇹 Italy – birthplace and spiritual home
- 🇺🇸 United States – a top searched pasta dish
- 🇬🇧 United Kingdom – popular in London’s trattorias
- 🇨🇦 Canada – beloved in Montreal and Toronto
- 🇦🇺 Australia – flourishing in urban food scenes
- 🇩🇪 Germany – gaining traction in Berlin
- 🇫🇷 France – respected in high-end cuisin
- 🇯🇵 Japan – admired for its simplicity
- 🇦🇷 Argentina – part of Italian heritage cooking
- 🇧🇷 Brazil – blending classic Italian comfort with vibrant, bold flavors
Infused with the richness of olive oil and butter, this version of Cacio e Pepe reimagines the Roman favorite with a sleek, modern twist—bringing consistent flavor and a velvety, indulgent finish.
Curious for more rich, comfort-style dishes? Take a look at my Spinach and Mushroom Quiche recipe—another creamy classic perfect for brunch or dinner.
Print
7 Proven Ways To Make Cacio E Pepe With Olive Oil and Butter That Never Clumps
- Total Time: 20 minutes
- Yield: 4 servings 1x
- Diet: Vegetarian
Description
Creamy and bold, this cacio e pepe with olive oil and butter blends Roman tradition with modern comfort. Learn the secret to perfect, clump-free pasta.
Ingredients
- 12 oz spaghetti or bucatini (best pasta for cacio e pepe)
- 1 cup freshly grated Pecorino Romano
- 3 tbsp unsalted butter
- 2 tbsp extra virgin olive oil
- 1 ½ tsp freshly cracked black pepper
- Salt, to taste
Optional Add-ins (Still Traditional-Friendly)
- Reserved pasta water (at least 1 cup)
- Parmesan cheese for garnish (not traditional, but adds richness)
- A touch of garlic (for depth)
Instructions
- Cook the Pasta
- Boil pasta in heavily salted water until just shy of al dente.
- Save at least 1 cup of pasta water before draining.
- Prepare the Sauce Base
- In a skillet, melt butter and olive oil over medium heat.
- Add freshly cracked black pepper and toast for 1 minute.
- Create Emulsion
- Add ½ cup reserved pasta water to skillet, let it simmer.
- Stir in cheese gradually while whisking to create a creamy emulsion.
- Combine Pasta and Sauce
- Add pasta to skillet and toss vigorously with tongs.
- Adjust with more pasta water as needed for desired texture.
- Serve Immediately
- Garnish with extra cheese and pepper.
- Serve in warm bowls to prevent clumping.
- Prep Time: 5 minutes
- Cook Time: 15 minutes
- Category: Dinner
- Method: Stovetop
- Cuisine: Roman / Italian
🧂 What You’ll Need
Preparing the perfect Cacio e Pepe with Olive Oil and Butter begins with having the right tools and top-quality ingredients. This dish is simple by nature, but precision and preparation make all the difference in achieving that silky, clump-free texture.
🛒 Essential Kitchen Tools
The tools you use help ensure each element of this dish is prepared with care. Here’s what I rely on when making Cacio e Pepe with Olive Oil and Butter at home:
- Large pot – Use a deep pot for boiling pasta to maintain water temperature.
- Skillet or sauté pan – A wide, flat-bottom pan makes emulsification easier.
- Tongs – Perfect for gently mixing pasta and sauce while keeping the noodles intact.
- Cheese grater – Grating fresh cheese ensures it melts smoothly and blends seamlessly into the sauce.
- Wooden spoon or silicone spatula – Gentle on cookware and great for stirring sauces and pasta.
🍽 Special Tips for Perfect Results
Even if you’re a beginner, these pro-level insights will elevate your version of Cacio e Pepe with Olive Oil and Butter:
- ✅ Use bronze-cut pasta – Its rough texture grips the cheese and pepper emulsion better than smooth pasta.
- ✅ Crack your pepper fresh – Pre-ground pepper lacks the bite and aroma of freshly crushed black peppercorns.
- ✅ Use Pecorino Romano, not Parmesan – Parmesan is milder, while Pecorino delivers that sharp, salty punch key to authenticity.
- ✅ Control your heat – Emulsions are delicate. Too much heat can break the sauce or make the cheese gritty.
These simple upgrades transform a basic bowl into a restaurant-worthy plate of Cacio e Pepe with Olive Oil and Butter.
🧾 Ingredients
The magic of Cacio e Pepe with Olive Oil and Butter lies in using minimal ingredients that deliver maximum flavor. Though it may look simple on paper, each component plays a vital role in the final texture, taste, and creaminess of the dish.
🧈 Core Ingredients for Success
Here’s everything you’ll need to bring your Cacio e Pepe with Olive Oil and Butter to life:
- 12 oz spaghetti or bucatini – Choose bronze‑cut pasta for better sauce adhesion.
- 1 cup Pecorino Romano, freshly grated – Don’t use pre-shredded; it clumps and doesn’t melt evenly.
- 3 tbsp unsalted butter – Adds creaminess and depth.
- 2 tbsp extra virgin olive oil – Boosts richness and creates a smooth emulsion.
- 1½ tsp freshly cracked black pepper – Toasted for an aromatic kick.
- Salt, to taste – Only needed for the pasta water.
👉 Like creamy dishes? Try the Creamy Korean Potato Salad — it’s another silky favorite with a bold twist.
✅ Optional Add‑ins (Still Tradition‑Respecting)
These ingredients aren’t strictly traditional but can improve flavor, appearance, or creaminess while staying true to the Roman spirit:
- Reserved pasta water (at least 1 cup) – Critical for emulsifying the sauce.
- Grated Parmesan cheese – Adds a touch of nutty richness alongside Pecorino.
- 1 garlic clove, smashed (optional) – Lightly sauté in oil for a warm, earthy background note.
- Lemon zest or parsley – For those who want a fresh finish without disrupting the classic flavor profile.
This balance of traditional and flexible ingredients is what makes Cacio e Pepe with Olive Oil and Butter such a universally loved dish — it’s deeply Roman, yet open to interpretation.
👉 Still struggling to get the sauce silky? You’ll love my method in this Creamy Korean Potato Salad, which uses a similar emulsification trick with starchy water and fats.
👨🍳 Instructions
To make restaurant-quality Cacio e Pepe with Olive Oil and Butter at home, precision is key. The secret isn’t in complex ingredients — it’s in mastering timing, heat control, and the elusive emulsion technique. Let’s walk through it step-by-step so you never end up with clumpy cheese or watery sauce again.
🍝 1. Boil the Pasta Just Right
Start by bringing a large pot of heavily salted water to a rolling boil. Drop in the spaghetti or bucatini, giving it a gentle stir now and then to keep the strands from clumping together. Cook until just shy of al dente — about 8–9 minutes, depending on the brand. Just before draining, be sure to reserve at least 1 cup of the pasta water to help bring your sauce together.
Why is this important? The starchy pasta water acts as a natural thickener and is crucial for creating the silky emulsion that defines Cacio e Pepe with Olive Oil and Butter.
🧈 2. Build the Flavorful Sauce Base
In a wide skillet over medium heat, melt 3 tablespoons of butter with 2 tablespoons of olive oil. Sprinkle in freshly cracked black pepper and let it gently toast for about 1 minute, releasing its bold, aromatic flavor. This blooming process releases the pepper’s aromatic oils and gives the dish its signature kick.
Carefully ladle in ½ cup of the reserved pasta water. Let it simmer gently while you whisk — the mixture should look glossy. Reduce the heat to low before adding the cheese in the next step to prevent it from seizing or clumping.
🥣 Create Emulsion & Serve
Bringing everything together is the most critical part of making Cacio e Pepe with Olive Oil and Butter. This is when the cheese, pepper, butter, and olive oil come into perfect harmony, forming a creamy sauce that hugs every strand of pasta.
🥄 3. Create the Cheese Emulsion
With your butter and olive oil base simmering gently, it’s time to stir in the cheese. Reduce the heat to low — or remove the skillet entirely from the heat — then gradually add the freshly grated Pecorino Romano, stirring constantly. Aim to melt the cheese gently into a silky, pepper-speckled emulsion—avoiding any clumps for a smooth, cohesive sauce.
To loosen the texture, add more reserved pasta water a tablespoon at a time. The starch from the water helps stabilize the sauce, giving your Cacio e Pepe with Olive Oil and Butter that signature silkiness.
This step can be tricky, but success comes from maintaining gentle heat, whisking continuously, and slowly incorporating the cheese for a flawless emulsion. Done correctly, it creates a glossy finish without any gritty texture.
🍽 4. Toss and Serve Immediately
As soon as the sauce reaches a smooth consistency, quickly toss in the hot, drained pasta to help it absorb all that creamy goodness. Toss it thoroughly with tongs to coat every noodle evenly. This ensures the cheese and pepper sauce binds completely to the pasta, delivering bold flavor in every bite.
Plate your Cacio e Pepe with Olive Oil and Butter into pre-warmed bowls to keep the emulsion from setting too quickly. Finish with more Pecorino Romano and a final crack of black pepper on top.
This dish must be served hot — it’s at its peak when the sauce is at its glossiest and most aromatic. When done right, Cacio e Pepe with Olive Oil and Butter becomes a creamy, indulgent masterpiece that balances simplicity and elegance with every twirl.
⏱ Prep Time, Cook Time, and Total Time
One of the biggest advantages of making Cacio e Pepe with Olive Oil and Butter is how fast it comes together — without sacrificing flavor. Whether you’re planning a quick weeknight dinner or want to impress guests with a timeless Italian dish, the total time investment is minimal.
⏳ Efficient and Quick Cooking
- Prep Time: 5 minutes
- Cook Time: 15 minutes
- Total Time: 20 minutes
This means you can start and finish your Cacio e Pepe with Olive Oil and Butter in under half an hour. It’s the kind of meal that delivers gourmet satisfaction without spending hours at the stove. The only prep you truly need is grating the Pecorino Romano and cracking fresh black pepper — everything else happens fast.
🥄 Why Timing Matters
Because Cacio e Pepe with Olive Oil and Butter is built on emulsion and temperature control, keeping things moving is essential. If the pasta cools too long after draining, or the cheese is added over high heat, the sauce can break.
Have everything — pasta water, cheese, butter, oil, and pepper — ready to go before you combine. The rhythm and pacing bring the dish to life, adding a special touch to its creation.
To enjoy it at its peak, serve right after mixing for the freshest flavor and texture. Letting it sit causes the sauce to thicken or congeal, which takes away from the luxurious mouthfeel that Cacio e Pepe with Olive Oil and Butter is known for.
🥡 Serving & Storage
When your Cacio e Pepe with Olive Oil and Butter reaches that silky, piping-hot perfection, every second counts. This dish thrives on immediacy — the creaminess, aroma, and flavor all peak right after plating. But what if you’re planning ahead or end up with leftovers?
Don’t worry — I’ve got tips to preserve the texture and revive the sauce later without losing the magic of Cacio e Pepe with Olive Oil and Butter.
🍴 Best Practices for Serving
- Serve immediately in warm bowls. Cold plates can cause the sauce to tighten up and separate.
- Top it off with a generous sprinkle of Pecorino Romano and a dash of freshly cracked black pepper
- Twirl the pasta into nests before plating for visual appeal and even heat distribution.
If you’re making Cacio e Pepe with Olive Oil and Butter for guests, have the table ready in advance so the dish can go from skillet to plate without delay.
❄️ How to Store and Reheat
Although Cacio e Pepe with Olive Oil and Butter is best fresh, you can store leftovers if needed:
- Keep it sealed in an airtight container and refrigerate for up to 2 days.
- To reheat, place the pasta in a nonstick skillet over low heat.
- Add a splash of hot water and a drizzle of olive oil to reconstitute the emulsion.
- Stir gently until creamy — avoid microwaving, which can cause the cheese to separate.
👉 Want more make-ahead ideas that reheat beautifully? Don’t miss my crowd-pleasing Pancake Casserole Recipe — it’s another comforting dish that’s great as leftovers!
🌀 Variations
One of the beauties of Cacio e Pepe with Olive Oil and Butter is its versatility. While the core ingredients are sacred to Roman tradition, there’s room for creativity without compromising the dish’s integrity. These variations offer something for health-conscious eaters, bold flavor lovers, and those experimenting with pantry staples.
🌱 Health-Conscious Modifications
If you’re looking to lighten up Cacio e Pepe with Olive Oil and Butter without losing flavor, these simple swaps can help:
- Use whole wheat spaghetti for added fiber and a slightly nutty depth.
- Swap traditional butter for vegan butter or reduce the amount and add more olive oil.
- Try a reduced-sodium Pecorino Romano to manage salt intake.
These changes maintain the creamy richness of Cacio e Pepe with Olive Oil and Butter, but add a more health-focused spin, especially great for weekday meals.
🧄 Flavor Boost & Style Tweaks
Want to add more complexity? Small adjustments can completely transform the dish while keeping the soul of Cacio e Pepe with Olive Oil and Butter intact:
- Add garlic — lightly sautéed in the olive oil for depth.
- Lemon zest adds brightness without competing with the cheese.
- Finish with a sprinkle of fresh parsley for vibrant color and a refreshing herbal touch.
- Add a touch of black garlic or a drizzle of truffle oil for an elegant, indulgent twist—used sparingly for maximum impact.
You can also tilt the fat balance depending on your preference:
- A butter-heavy version offers a thick, glossy texture and richer mouthfeel.
- An olive oil–focused variation offers a lighter, silkier texture and a more vibrant, refreshing taste.
Looking for more bold Italian twists? My Stuffed Pepper Casserole is another hearty, customizable dish that pairs well with simple salads and wine.
❓ Frequently Asked Questions
What is the secret to a silky, smooth sauce?
The secret lies in building a stable emulsion — a perfect blend of cheese, pasta water, butter, and olive oil. Keeping the temperature low while whisking gradually helps the Pecorino Romano melt into a silky sauce instead of clumping.
Why does the cheese clump in my Cacio e Pepe with Olive Oil and Butter?
Clumping usually happens when the cheese is added over high heat or the pan is too hot. Always remove the skillet from direct heat before stirring in the cheese. Also, use freshly grated Pecorino Romano, not pre-shredded varieties.
What type of pasta works best for Cacio e Pepe with Olive Oil and Butter?
Spaghetti or bucatini are traditional and highly recommended. Even better, use bronze-cut pasta, which has a rough surface that grabs onto the creamy sauce perfectly.
Is Cacio e Pepe with Olive Oil and Butter traditional?
While the classic Roman version uses only pasta, Pecorino, and black pepper, the addition of olive oil and butter is a modern tweak that helps stabilize the sauce and eliminate clumping. It respects tradition while offering consistency and ease — especially for home cooks.
🏁 Conclusion
Cacio e Pepe with Olive Oil and Butter is proof that a few humble ingredients — pasta, cheese, pepper, butter, and olive oil — can come together to create something extraordinary. Whether you’re cooking for one, hosting friends, or indulging in a late-night craving, this dish delivers timeless flavor with modern ease.
Mastering Cacio e Pepe with Olive Oil and Butter means more than just tossing pasta with cheese — it’s about technique, timing, and balance. With butter and olive oil added, the sauce becomes smoother, the flavors deeper, and the result far more consistent, especially for home cooks.
This creamy variation doesn’t just respect the Roman roots of the dish — it elevates it. Every forkful is coated with that velvety emulsion and finished with bold black pepper and the sharp tang of Pecorino Romano.
If you’ve enjoyed this dish, I highly recommend trying out more comforting Italian flavors like my Lemon Dump Cake — a sweet finish to a savory pasta night.
In just 20 minutes, you can master one of Italy’s greatest comfort foods. And once you do, Cacio e Pepe with Olive Oil and Butter will earn a permanent place in your weeknight dinner rotation.